Metacarpal fractures are one of the most common fractures of the upper extremity. They are often divided into fractures of the head, neck, and shaft.
Metacarpal Head
Metacarpal Neck
Metacarpal Shaft
Metacarpal Base
×
Metacarpal Head Fracture
Head fractures are rare and you will likely not encounter these much. Fractures of the neck, shaft, and base are more commonly seen.
Head Fractures
• These are generally intraarticular. The fractures are often comminuted.
• They can be seen with dorsal MP dislocations. Therefore, if you treat an MP dislocation, look out for the metacarpal head fracture.
• If the patient has a metacarpal head fracture in association with a clenched fist injury (punching someone in the mouth), assume that the wound has oral contamination, and these must be treated with formal irrigation and debridement in the operating room.
• Radiographic evaluation includes posteroanterior, lateral, and oblique views. A Brewerton view may be performed for better visualization of the articular surface, but this should not be necessary in an ED setting.
1 of 4
38-year-old female who was attacked by a dog. She sustained this comminuted 2nd metacarpal fracture with main articular piece completely displaced and between the metacarpals.
ED Management
• These fractures will not need a reduction.
When to Call Hand Surgery:
• The fracture is open: the skin over the fracture is open and there is a track down to bone.
◦ Most commonly, this is due to a penetrating mechanism for metacarpal head fractures. So you will see these in knife or gun injuries.
• Otherwise, please splint to protect the fracture, then have patient follow up outpatient with a hand surgeon within 1 week.
Counseling the Patient:
• The treatment of metacarpal head fractures are individualized.
• Nevertheless, a majority of these will require surgery. It is imperative that the patient be seen as soon as possible in a Hand Surgery clinic.
×
Metacarpal Neck Fracture Algorithm
Metacarpal Neck Fracture
↓
ASSESSMENT:
• Which metacarpal?
• Degree of angulation
• Rotation
• Open vs closed
Acceptable Angulation: Index MC: 10-15° Long MC: 10-15° Ring MC: 20-30° Small MC: 30-40°
↓
WITHIN LIMITS
Closed reduction Ulnar gutter splint F/u 5-7 days Repeat X-rays
EXCEEDS LIMITS
URGENT ORIF K-wires or Intramedullary fixation
Key Points - "Boxer's Fracture" (5th MC Neck):
• Most common metacarpal fracture
• Usually from punching mechanism
• Up to 40° angulation acceptable in small finger MC
• Pseudo-clawing may occur with >30° angulation
• Index and long fingers tolerate much less angulation
• ANY malrotation requires reduction/fixation
Closed reduction Splint/cast F/u 5-7 days Check for loss of reduction
UNSTABLE
URGENT ORIF Plates/screws or K-wires or IM fixation
Key Points:
• Spiral/oblique fractures tend to be more unstable
• Shortening creates extensor lag and weakness
• Border digits (index, small) less tolerant of deformity
• Transverse fractures may be amenable to closed reduction
• Long oblique fractures ideal for lag screw fixation
URGENT ORIF or CRPP Closed reduction unstable APL pulls proximal fragment
ROLANDO FRACTURE (3+ part comminuted)
URGENT SURGERY ORIF if reconstructable External fixation if comminuted
↓
CMC Dislocation (2nd-5th)?
YES
URGENT CRPP or ORIF Highly unstable Risk of chronic instability
NO - Extra-articular
Displacement?
MINIMAL
Short arm cast or splint F/u 1 week
DISPLACED
CRPP or ORIF depending on stability
Key Points:
• Bennett's fracture: Classic 2-part intra-articular at thumb CMC
• Volar-ulnar fragment held by volar ligament, proximal fragment pulled by APL
• CMC dislocations often missed on initial X-rays - get oblique views
• 2nd-3rd CMC have minimal motion, 4th-5th more mobile
• Reverse Bennett (5th MC base): Similar management to Bennett's
• Most CMC fracture-dislocations require operative fixation